CRZ Expectations

Expectations about New York City's congestion pricing program, written down before the data arrived and scored automatically once it did.

Scored Nov 12, 2026 at 06:26 UTC. Page built Nov 12, 2026 at 06:27 UTC. Registry at commit 3a53f61.

Expert's record on prospective expectations: none of the 7 has been scored yet. Their data is not published. This line will report how many held against the confidence the expert stated.

How to read this

An expectation is a written statement of what a metric should do over a set of dates, with a range. It is recorded in a registry that can only be added to. When the data for its dates is loaded, the pipeline computes the observed value and gives a verdict.

The expected ranges here come from an AI agent acting as a subject matter expert, interviewed and checked by the engineer. The full interview is public. In real use the experts would be people.

Held
The observed value fell inside the expected range.
Violated: below
The observed value fell below the expected range.
Violated: above
The observed value fell above the expected range.
Pending
The data for this window is not published or loaded yet.
Data issue
A data check on this expectation's inputs failed, so the result is not trusted.
Not scoreable
No data this project holds shares the expectation's baseline. It is shown for context.
Prospective
Recorded before the data for its window was published.
Derived
An expert's translation of an official projection onto a metric this project measures.
Official
Published by an agency before the outcome.
Retrospective
Recorded after the data was seen. It checks the pipeline or marks what to watch. It does not test a forecast.
Where the gap comes from
For expectations about a change between two periods, the gap between observed and expected is split by slices such as service or entry point. Every slice is assumed to have been expected to move by the same percentage. This shows where a gap sits. It does not say why.

Prospective expectations

Recorded before the data for its window was published.

Pending Prospective

In the week of November 8 to 14, 2026, about 4% fewer vehicles will enter the Congestion Relief Zone than in the matching week of 2025.

Expected -7.50% to -1.00%

Expected -7.50% to -1.00%. Not observed yet.-7.50%-1.00%

The data for this window is not published or loaded yet. Data is loaded through 2026-10-31.

No data yet for Nov 8, 2026 to Nov 14, 2026. The comparison window has 7 days behind it.

No data yet for Nov 8, 2026 to Nov 14, 2026. The comparison window has 7 days behind it. Solid line: the window. Dashed line: the comparison window.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Nov 8, 2026 to Nov 14, 2026
Compared with
Nov 9, 2025 to Nov 15, 2025
Metric
crz_entries
Stated confidence
80%

November 8 to 10 had passed when this was recorded, but the MTA had not published them, and the expert used no information from those days.

Pending Prospective

Yellow taxis will make about 5% fewer trips in October 2026 than in October 2025.

Expected -11.00% to +1.00%

Expected -11.00% to +1.00%. Not observed yet.-11.00%+1.00%

The data for this window is not published or loaded yet. Data is loaded through 2026-09-30.

No data yet for Oct 1, 2026 to Oct 31, 2026. The comparison window has 31 days behind it.

No data yet for Oct 1, 2026 to Oct 31, 2026. The comparison window has 31 days behind it. Solid line: the window. Dashed line: the comparison window.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Oct 1, 2026 to Oct 31, 2026
Compared with
Oct 2, 2025 to Nov 1, 2025
Metric
tlc_trips, service = yellow
Stated confidence
80%
Pending Prospective

Uber and Lyft together will make about 3 to 4% more trips in October 2026 than in October 2025.

Expected -0.50% to +7.00%

Expected -0.50% to +7.00%. Not observed yet.-0.50%+7.00%

The data for this window is not published or loaded yet. Data is loaded through 2026-09-30.

No data yet for Oct 1, 2026 to Oct 31, 2026. The comparison window has 31 days behind it.

No data yet for Oct 1, 2026 to Oct 31, 2026. The comparison window has 31 days behind it. Solid line: the window. Dashed line: the comparison window.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Oct 1, 2026 to Oct 31, 2026
Compared with
Oct 2, 2025 to Nov 1, 2025
Metric
tlc_trips, service = fhvhv
Stated confidence
80%
Pending Prospective

The number of ride-hail trips per yellow taxi trip will rise about 9% from October 2025 to October 2026.

Expected +2.00% to +16.50%

Expected +2.00% to +16.50%. Not observed yet.+2.00%+16.50%

The data for this window is not published or loaded yet. Data is loaded through 2026-09-30.

No data yet for Oct 1, 2026 to Oct 31, 2026. The comparison window has 31 days behind it.

No data yet for Oct 1, 2026 to Oct 31, 2026. The comparison window has 31 days behind it. Solid line: the window. Dashed line: the comparison window.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Oct 1, 2026 to Oct 31, 2026
Compared with
Oct 2, 2025 to Nov 1, 2025
Metric
fhvhv_per_yellow
Stated confidence
80%

Drivers are not broken down for a ratio metric; see the two trip entries for each service.

Pending Prospective

Private cars, pickups and vans entering the zone in November 2026 will be about 7 to 8% below November 2025.

Expected -11.00% to -4.00%

Expected -11.00% to -4.00%. Not observed yet.-11.00%-4.00%

The data for this window is not published or loaded yet. Data is loaded through 2026-10-31.

No data yet for Nov 1, 2026 to Nov 28, 2026. The comparison window has 28 days behind it.

No data yet for Nov 1, 2026 to Nov 28, 2026. The comparison window has 28 days behind it. Solid line: the window. Dashed line: the comparison window.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Nov 1, 2026 to Nov 28, 2026
Compared with
Nov 2, 2025 to Nov 29, 2025
Metric
crz_entries, vehicle_class = cars_pickups_vans
Stated confidence
80%
Pending Prospective

Taxis and for-hire vehicles entering the zone in November 2026 will be roughly flat to slightly up on November 2025.

Expected -2.00% to +5.00%

Expected -2.00% to +5.00%. Not observed yet.-2.00%+5.00%

The data for this window is not published or loaded yet. Data is loaded through 2026-10-31.

No data yet for Nov 1, 2026 to Nov 28, 2026. The comparison window has 28 days behind it.

No data yet for Nov 1, 2026 to Nov 28, 2026. The comparison window has 28 days behind it. Solid line: the window. Dashed line: the comparison window.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Nov 1, 2026 to Nov 28, 2026
Compared with
Nov 2, 2025 to Nov 29, 2025
Metric
crz_entries, vehicle_class = tlc_taxi_fhv
Stated confidence
80%
Pending Prospective

The week of November 15 to 21, 2026 will look like a normal week, with 3 to 6 of its 7 days of zone entries inside their usual range.

Expected 42.8% of days to 85.8% of days

Expected 42.8% of days to 85.8% of days. Not observed yet.42.8% of days85.8% of days

The data for this window is not published or loaded yet. Data is loaded through 2026-10-31.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Nov 15, 2026 to Nov 21, 2026
Metric
crz_entries
Stated confidence
80%

Assumes baselines use Spark's exact percentile (linear interpolation), as the spec requires. Day of week was requested as a driver but is not a dimension.

Derived expectations

An expert's translation of an official projection onto a metric this project measures.

Held Derived

If the official forecast's logic held, taxi and ride-hail trips to or from the zone in tolling's first year would be roughly flat against the year before.

Observed +1.72%, expected -2.50% to +4.00%

Observed +1.72%. Expected -2.50% to +4.00%.-2.50%+4.00%

The observed value fell inside the expected range.

Daily tlc_cbd_touch_trips from Jan 5, 2025 to Jan 3, 2026: 364 days, between 149,927 and 464,845. The comparison window has 364 days behind it.

Daily tlc_cbd_touch_trips from Jan 5, 2025 to Jan 3, 2026: 364 days, between 149,927 and 464,845. The comparison window has 364 days behind it. Solid line: the window. Dashed line: the comparison window.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Jan 5, 2025 to Jan 3, 2026
Compared with
Jan 7, 2024 to Jan 4, 2025
Metric
tlc_cbd_touch_trips
Stated confidence
80%
Where the gap comes from

By service

SliceGapShare of gap
yellow+4,637,079+424%
fhvhv-3,543,880-324%

By zone_relation

SliceGapShare of gap
pickup_in+665,512+61%
dropoff_in+276,390+25%
both_in+151,297+14%

Gaps are in the metric's unit over the whole window. When the result lands near the middle of its range the total gap is small, so shares are large and can have opposite signs.

This window's data was loaded and largely published when this was recorded, so a hit says nothing about forecasting skill. Score it as a test of the projection's logic. The expert's own estimate, given published data, is +0.5% to +3.0%. Not counted toward calibration.

Official expectations

Published by an agency before the outcome.

Not scoreable Official

The $9 Phase 1 toll reduces daily vehicles entering the Manhattan CBD by 13.4% relative to No Action.

No data this project holds shares the expectation's baseline. It is shown for context. The public entries data begins at launch, and no action is a modeled counterfactual for a 2023 analysis year, so no series this project observes shares the projection's baseline. the mta's own headline counts also add excluded roadways to zone entries..

Recorded
Nov 1, 2024 by the agency
Window
Jan 5, 2025 to Jan 4, 2026
Reported elsewhere
-11.0 percent. 27 million fewer vehicles entering the zone in year one. The release does not name its baseline.

Retrospective expectations

Recorded after the data was seen. It checks the pipeline or marks what to watch. It does not test a forecast.

Held Retrospective

In tolling's first year there were about 5 ride-hail trips for every yellow taxi trip, down from 5.8 in 2024, because yellow trips surged.

Observed 4.99, expected 4.93 to 5.07

Observed 4.99. Expected 4.93 to 5.07.4.935.07

The observed value fell inside the expected range.

Daily fhvhv_per_yellow from Jan 5, 2025 to Jan 3, 2026: 364 days, between 4 and 8.

Daily fhvhv_per_yellow from Jan 5, 2025 to Jan 3, 2026: 364 days, between 4 and 8.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Jan 5, 2025 to Jan 3, 2026
Metric
fhvhv_per_yellow
Stated confidence
95%

Drivers are not supported for this comparison.

A consistency check with no evidential weight, because the value was known when recorded.

Held Retrospective

The pipeline reproduces the MTA's figure that yellow and ride-hail trips starting or ending in the zone rose about 0.8% from January to September 2024 to the same months of 2025.

Observed +0.79%, expected +0.30% to +1.40%

Observed +0.79%. Expected +0.30% to +1.40%.+0.30%+1.40%

The observed value fell inside the expected range.

Daily tlc_cbd_touch_trips from Jan 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2025: 273 days, between 202,062 and 414,107. The comparison window has 274 days behind it.

Daily tlc_cbd_touch_trips from Jan 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2025: 273 days, between 202,062 and 414,107. The comparison window has 274 days behind it. Solid line: the window. Dashed line: the comparison window.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Jan 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2025
Compared with
Jan 1, 2024 to Sep 30, 2024
Metric
tlc_cbd_touch_trips
Stated confidence
85%
Where the gap comes from

By service

SliceGapShare of gap
fhvhv-3,533,646+7,483%
yellow+3,486,421-7,383%

By zone_relation

SliceGapShare of gap
both_in-165,065+350%
pickup_in+143,162-303%
dropoff_in-25,321+54%

Gaps are in the metric's unit over the whole window. When the result lands near the middle of its range the total gap is small, so shares are large and can have opposite signs.

Reproduces a published figure to validate the pipeline; not a forecast. If the yellow and ride-hail reproductions pass but this misses, check what the unfiltered metric includes.

Held Retrospective

The pipeline reproduces the MTA's figure that yellow taxi trips starting or ending in the zone rose about 17% from January to September 2024 to the same months of 2025.

Observed +16.71%, expected +15.90% to +17.90%

Observed +16.71%. Expected +15.90% to +17.90%.+15.90%+17.90%

The observed value fell inside the expected range.

Daily tlc_cbd_touch_trips from Jan 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2025: 273 days, between 53,035 and 129,715. The comparison window has 274 days behind it.

Daily tlc_cbd_touch_trips from Jan 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2025: 273 days, between 53,035 and 129,715. The comparison window has 274 days behind it. Solid line: the window. Dashed line: the comparison window.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Jan 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2025
Compared with
Jan 1, 2024 to Sep 30, 2024
Metric
tlc_cbd_touch_trips, service = yellow
Stated confidence
85%
Where the gap comes from

By zone_relation

SliceGapShare of gap
pickup_in-117,725+285%
dropoff_in+63,913-155%
both_in+12,491-30%

Gaps are in the metric's unit over the whole window. When the result lands near the middle of its range the total gap is small, so shares are large and can have opposite signs.

Reproduces a published figure to validate the pipeline; not a forecast.

Held Retrospective

The pipeline reproduces the MTA's figure that ride-hail trips starting or ending in the zone fell about 5% from January to September 2024 to the same months of 2025.

Observed -4.86%, expected -5.60% to -4.20%

Observed -4.86%. Expected -5.60% to -4.20%.-5.60%-4.20%

The observed value fell inside the expected range.

Daily tlc_cbd_touch_trips from Jan 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2025: 273 days, between 142,609 and 293,809. The comparison window has 274 days behind it.

Daily tlc_cbd_touch_trips from Jan 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2025: 273 days, between 142,609 and 293,809. The comparison window has 274 days behind it. Solid line: the window. Dashed line: the comparison window.

Recorded
Nov 11, 2026 by an AI agent acting as subject matter expert (interview)
Window
Jan 1, 2025 to Sep 30, 2025
Compared with
Jan 1, 2024 to Sep 30, 2024
Metric
tlc_cbd_touch_trips, service = fhvhv
Stated confidence
85%
Where the gap comes from

By operator_code

SliceGapShare of gap
HV0005+2,058,044+7,632%
HV0003-2,031,079-7,532%

By zone_relation

SliceGapShare of gap
both_in-623,801-2,313%
pickup_in+593,026+2,199%
dropoff_in+57,740+214%

Gaps are in the metric's unit over the whole window. When the result lands near the middle of its range the total gap is small, so shares are large and can have opposite signs.

Reproduces a published figure to validate the pipeline; not a forecast.

Data health

The latest result of each data check. A check is a claim about the data, such as "this column is never empty". A failing check on an expectation's inputs turns its verdict into a data issue.

CheckStatusPassWarnFailDetail
cbd_zone_membershipWarning 010 2025: 1,823,293 of 1,922,810 trips that start and end in the same in-zone zone carry the fee (2025-01-05 to 2025-12-31)
dropoff_before_pickupPass 9000
dropped_sharePass 9000
entries_days_completePass 2200
fee_before_launchPass 100
fee_presencePass 9000
freshnessPass 300
regression_totalsPass 600
required_nullsPass 9000
schema_required_columnsPass 9000
silver_volumePass 8400

Freshness

How far each source is loaded against what it has published.

SourceStatusDetail
crz_entriesPassLoaded through 2026-10-31; published through 2026-10-31
fhvhvPassLoaded through 2026-09; published through 2026-09
yellowPassLoaded through 2026-09; published through 2026-09